Showing posts with label Fighting Corruption. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fighting Corruption. Show all posts

Thursday, February 20, 2020

Neo-colonialism & the South Fly

Martyn Namarong

By MARTYN NAMORONG - PNG Attitude

PORT MORESBY - Recent media reports have highlighted the problems faced by Daru in terms of its ailing infrastructure and the chronic shortages of almost everything that could make urban life liveable.
Daru is a stone’s throw away from the first world existence of Australia yet a million miles away from access to reliable safe clean drinking water, decent sanitation and healthcare. Port Moresby doesn’t know Daru although it pretends to call it the capital of its Western Province. What Port Moresby knows about its neo-colonial territory of Western Province is the giant Ok Tedi copper mine which is Papua New Guinea’s main foreign exchange earner.
To understand what is wrong with South Fly is to first look at the big picture before delving down into the minutiae of the problems faced by this district.
THE BIG PICTURE
South Fly District is carved out of mainland PNG by the Fly River which runs from the northwest PNG-Indonesia border towards the south east into the Coral Sea. It has a land mass of over 31,000 square kilometers, enough to fit in the highlands provinces of Simbu, Eastern Highlands, Western Highlands and Jiwaka and still have a lot of breathing space.
The district’s enormous size presents a logistical nightmare when trying to deliver basic government services to people scattered over such a large area. This is further compounded by the fact that, like every other district in PNG, it only receives around K10 million each year from the national government. Imagine trying to deliver goods and services to the provinces of Simbu, Eastern Highlands, Western Highlands and Jiwaka with only K10 million.
Its problems are also structural. Some of these issues are unique to the district and are the outcomes of broader historical processes that have produced present realities. When PNG gained independence in 1975, the preamble to its constitution declared the nation’s self-affirmation on the global stage. However, in its subsequent sections, the constitution also gave effect to the instruments and institutions of colonisation.
In effect the PNG constitution is a bit of an oxymoron in that it declares a PNG identity and then goes on to suppress that by empowering the tools of colonial power. The consequence of this constitutional contradiction is that colonisation in PNG now has a Melanesian face with the neo-colonial powers being in Waigani and the colonies at the periphery.
Thus, for the people of South Fly, those along the borders of Indonesia and Australia had their fate sealed by Port Moresby, Canberra and Jakarta. Take for example the ‘treaty villages’ along the Torres Strait which have been deprived of any commercial gains from fisheries thanks to the Torres Straits Treaty. Although one would assume the border villages would be far more developed given their proximity to larger and more advanced economies, they are amongst the most poorest and disadvantaged in the district.
Recent work done by Professor Mark Moran and his team from the University of Queensland show that the level of poverty in these areas is comparable to that of sub-Saharan Africa.
As Professor Moran and his team noted:
“The close pre-colonial relationships between people in the South Fly and Torres Strait Islands, which typically fostered mutual benefits for both parties, were transformed when PNG gained independence in 1975. Since then, the benefits coming to Torres Strait Islanders along with their Australian citizenship have steadily increased, lifting their living standards.
“Meanwhile, the situation in the South Fly has deteriorated: the people have received limited support from the PNG Government and environmental damage due to irresponsible mining practices has damaged the marine environment on which they depend.
“[The] asymmetries on the PNG side of the border have deepened further as the management of the Torres Strait Treaty has gradually hardened.”
Other structural problems are not unique to the people of South Fly. Waigani’s negative relationship with the periphery is well documented with the Bougainville civil war being the most infamous.
The growing calls for autonomy from the periphery reflect the level of mistrust felt by the margins of their neo-colonial masters in Waigani.
Take for instance the idiosyncrasies of the Waigani imposed administration. Provinces, districts, local level governments (LLGs) and wards exist merely as decorative shells giving a perception of administrative power and control by the regions.
Many ‘provincial’ sectors of administration are actually controlled from Port Moresby with neither the local political leaders nor administrators in charge. And so the ‘Provincial’ Police Commander is accountable to Konedobu, and the ‘District’ Finance Manager reports to the Finance Department in Waigani.
In Waigani’s language these are ‘national functions’ operating at the provincial or district level. The use of the terms ‘provincial’ or ‘district’ refer to geographic descriptions of the roles as opposed to any form of local political or administrative autonomy.
And so a major development challenge faced not just by South Fly but other regions of PNG is that the political and administrative heads of provinces, districts and LLGs are rather impotent when dealing with officers who are accountable to Waigani and not the local authorities.
How do these local generals command their soldiers when the soldiers receive marching orders from Waigani?
The battle against entropy in the provinces and districts is lost even before the war has begun because of the command structure. Thus entropy has won, is winning and will continue to win unless generals and soldiers are under one command structure.
What I am saying is nothing new. It was recognised at the dawn of PNG’s independence and has continued to be articulated by various parties in various forms.
Unfortunately, the viceroys of the new empire which was inherited from our colonial masters in 1975 remain stubborn in their grasp of power and privilege.
Thus when a Member for South Fly receives the K10 million district service improvement grant with all the strings Waigani has attached, it is dispensed according to Waigani’s guidelines to implementing officers who are ultimately accountable to Waigani.
The local member of parliament acts like a postmaster for Waigani. If one is to understand some of the unconventional behaviour of some MPs one must understand the power play and potential political suicide that faces them.
THE SMALL PICTURE
And with this we segue into the small picture for the people of South Fly.
Ask anyone on Daru Island what is wrong with service delivery and the two things they mention are lack of political leadership and a corrupt public service.
But, as I have noted earlier, whilst these two concerns are genuine, the problems are larger than that.
Both the political leadership and civil service face the unenviable task of delivering goods and services to a scattered population over a large geographical area with very limited resources.
The local MP, the police commander and education and health advisors simply do not have the capacity to deliver to the entire electorate. Yet they are expected to perform miracles. And when they fail they are accused of being corrupt.
Funds from Waigani also are notoriously late or never sent - and guess who gets blamed for the lack of service?
But on the occasion that funds do arrive, the administrative idiosyncrasies discussed earlier kick into place thus there is lack of accountability at the local level.
South Fly District is only as accountable as Waigani holds it to account. Even Daru has not much control over Daru as, in many cases, Daru reports to Waigani.
On Daru Island it’s always the next person who is the problem.
Everyone seems blindsided by their own self-righteousness. And so, as individuals fail to reflect on their own personal weakness and correct them, the process of growth and improvement fails to happen.
On my first trip down to Daru, I met a couple of District Development Authority board members who kept blaming the public servants for many of the issues in the district.
But as I looked through some of the decisions I wondered if the DDA board was not playing its role. Many of the board members I spoke to didn’t fully understand their roles and responsibilities.
I asked them, “Do you know that you are in charge of looking after the yam house that belongs to the people of South Fly?”
“Do you know that the rats cannot eat the yams unless you give approvals at the DDA board meetings?”
“How can you blame the rats for eating from the yams from the yam house when you gave approval to the rats to get hold of the yams at the first place?”
You can imagine how the board members performed at subsequent board meetings.
GOING FORWARD
There needs to be a lot of individual reflection and soul searching on Daru Island with more empathy for the next person on the island.
Everyone needs to examine their own strengths and weaknesses and to see the goodness in others that can be leveraged to move the district forward.
The people of South Fly need to recognise the systems and structures that have been imposed on them since 1975 and organise themselves better to be able to make the systems work for them.
Go to this link for more: https://www.pngattitude.com/2020/02/neo-colonialism-the-south-fly.html

Wednesday, February 19, 2020

Whistleblower act passed

Marape

By JAMES MARAPE
| Facebook | Extract
Yesterday PNG's parliament passed a law to protect whistleblowers but a bill to establish an Independent Commission Against Corruption will have to go to a parliamentary committee before being voted on. Mr Marape wrote this before parliament sat - KJ
PORT MORESBY - I gained office with no money, no political party, no lobbyist, and not too many friends except a few loyalists including MPs and the general people of Papua New Guinea who wanted change plus the Hand of my Creator God.
Please circulate that I don’t have agents and if anyone, whether the fake accounts holders in Facebook or others in private who might request help as if coming from me, report them.
Talk about fighting corruption, we hopefully should pass Independent Commission Against Corruption tomorrow (Tuesday).
It is in our government’s program and all MPs including the opposition have been told that this is a Marape-Steven government’s priority legislation, including whistle blowers act.
This ICAC bill will set the institution that should assist us fighting corruption and we will build it where it is free from politics and become an agent that assist transforming our country into the future.
Other lead corruption fighting agencies like Transparency International, the Ombudsman, the police plus the judiciary will be called upon to assist set up the structure of ICAC.
The Whistleblowers Act we will pass also protects those who report corruption so I request those who have evidence of corruption in our country, prepare to take cover under our Whistleblowers Act and report them.
Many governments have promised ICAC but myself and Hon Davis Steven as Attorney-General and our present parliament including ministers have pledged to deliver this [yesterday].
PNG, I placed minister Kramer to fight corruption and he is giving his best shot. I am slowly but surely placing public service appointments I feel will assist us get there, like the appointment of a reknowned corruption fighter Sam Koim to the Internal Revenue Commission, as a few small examples.
Rome was not built in one day or one year, we have a long way to go in PNG but we making the first correct painful baby steps.
When you see wrong and corruption, assist being an agent of law by providing your evidence and helping us take back PNG, instead of just being a Facebook or cyber complainant.
Whilst on corruption, the last few days an issue on a gas license transaction that took place during minister Duma’s time as petroleum minister has been a public concern.
I am concerned too and, just like other allegations, I have requested detailed scrutiny of this allegation raised by foreign media.
Minister Duma has been asked to provide his side of the story and into the future greater light will unravel this matter too.
Again if anyone of you have any interest or information on this then Facebook is not the forum but responsible offices including the police and Ombudsman.
This country is here to stay and some of these will be work in progress so have faith we will get there.
Let’s all work wherever we are placed.

Whistleblower Act passed



By HELEN TARAWA - The National
PARLIAMENT unanimously passed (90-0) the Whistleblower Act 2020, a giant step forward in PNG’s fight against corruption.
Deputy Prime Minister David Steven, the Minister for Justice and Attorney-General, said the legislation was part of the initiative to address corruption and will complement anti-corruption initiatives.
He said the new law was “a conduit for employees that note suspicious improprieties to make protected disclosure in accordance with relevant disclosure channels”.
“The concept of whistleblowing of impropriety has been introduced in other jurisdictions including our region. Often such disclosures have been difficult as employees who observed such improprieties risked being met with reprisals. “The bill is a modest approach in establishing protection mechanisms for employees,” he said.
He however warned that the bill was not the only solution to dealing with corruption.
“(It is) a piece of the anti-corruption system that will encourage a culture of accountability and transparency,” he said.
The new legislation is designed to:
  • provide procedures for employees to report suspected improprieties in the workplace;
  • Protect employees who make protected disclosures from occupational detriment; and,
  • Provide remedies to employees who suffer occupational detriment having made protected disclosures.
It enables employees to disclose any suspicious impropriety within their workplace including a criminal offence, a failure to comply with a legal obligation, a miscarriage of justice, endangering the health and safety of an individual, environment damage, unfair discrimination and deliberately concealing any conduct mentioned above.
There are four types of protected disclosures;
  • A legal practitioner in the course of obtaining legal advice. It is protected disclosure only if the disclosure is done in good faith and in the course of obtaining legal advice.
  • protected discloser to an employer. If the disclosure is made in good faith and either made in accordance with an approved international reporting procedure or whether there is no approved international procedure directly to the employer or employee’s immediate supervisor.
  • protected disclosure to a minister. It also applies to statutory office holders and employees to statutory bodies who are not officers of the public service. It is protected disclosure if made in good faith and to the minister responsible for relevant Act or statutory body; and,
  • the protected disclosure to an approved authority.

Go to this link for more: https://www.thenational.com.pg/whistleblower-act-passed/

Monday, February 17, 2020

MARAPE REWARDS & EMBRACES CORRUPTION IF HE DOES NOT SACK DUMA



By Isabella Tauri - PNG Blog

Marape has again rewarded Mr Corruption and one of PNG people's greatest thief William DUMA through a Government Decision NOT to investigate further, effect arrest nor sack William DUMA as a State Minister!

Never forget this is the same William Corruption Duma who stole millions from the Manumanu Land Deal, together with Fabian Pok.  The people of PNG protested on Facebook for their removal but Peter O'Neill kept them until the Government changed in May 2019.
The people's expectations were on Marape to live by his words - to be the people's PM!  But Marape's true hidden colors are now showing.

First, he rewarded DUMA with a State Minister portfolio end of last year.  All for political survival!
Now that both local and international media has exposed DUMA's corruption in abusing public office as a State Minister for personal gain, Marape has made another decision to NOT DO ANYTHING about DUMA's corruption.

Instead, he is taking K28 Million of public funds to fund further investigation on the UBS Loan saga, which he himself as Finance Minister was 100% responsible for. 
We the people of PNG already got robbed of K3 Billion by Marape and his cohorts in the former O'Neill regime.  Why is he so defiant to ROB us AGAIN to pay hell knows who and what for money that we shall never recover?

The litmus test in now on Marape:   WILL HE BE A TRUE LEADER TO SACK DUMA AND INVESTIGATE HIM TOO?

If nothing is done then it may mean Marape himself may have personally benefited from these deals.  He will protect Duma at all costs!
The Fact that Marape embraces and rewards CORRUPTION means he is indeed an accessory to all these corruption and is corrupt as well.  He does not care about the welfare of Papua New Guineans as he plays lip service in his preachings.
So Papua New Guineans, stop your little Christian preachings, understand the magnitude of this corruption and decisions.
TIME TO START A NEW REVOLUTION AND REMOVE CORRUPT LEADERS!


Go to this link for more: http://www.pngblogs.com/2020/02/marape-rewards-embraces-corruption-if.html

Sunday, October 13, 2019

Corruption Bill to be presented



Posted on The National

THE much-awaited Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) Bill has been given the green light by Cabinet to be tabled in Parliament, according to Justice Minister and Attorney-General Davis Steven.
Deputy Prime Minister Steven, pictured, said the Organic Law on ICAC was an important legislation.
“I am pleased that this important legislation can now go to Parliament for deliberation by the nation’s law makers, hopefully, in the next seating of Parliament,” he said.
Steven said the legal team in the Department of Justice and Attorney-General had started working on the regulations required to operationalise ICAC.
He said Constitutional amendments to establish ICAC were passed in 2015. But there was little time to pass the Organic Law in the last term of Parliament.
“The passage of the Organic Law on ICAC has been delayed for many reasons including bureaucratic rigmarole,” he said.
“We have the opportunity to pass the legislation in the remaining months of this term of Parliament.
“Our Government is determined to have the ICAC established by 2022 as part of our strategy to combat corruption in the country.
“Citizens and interested groups can access the full text of the ICAC bill when it is published in the National Gazette for a period of one month as required by law.”
The ICAC bill will also be published in the department’s website.
All members of Parliament will be provided a copy of the bill at least one month before it is tabled.
“I have directed my department to follow these procedures strictly,” he said.
“Our people must participate meaningfully in the process of passing important laws that affect their lives.
“Laws must be made following consensus and not imposed upon the people.”

Go to this link for more: https://www.thenational.com.pg/corruption-bill-to-be-presented/

Wednesday, August 21, 2019

Koim challenges staff



Posted by The National

Acting commissioner general of the Internal Revenue Commission (IRC) Sam Koim says he has limited time and would like to make it count.
Koim, in his address to IRC staff in Port Moresby yesterday, said he was not there with a one-size fit all solution.
“I know that this great organisation has progressed well over the years under the leadership of then commissioner general Betty Palaso and commissioners Dr Alois Daton and Pauline Bre,” he said.
“Many of you have contributed to this progress so you should be proud,” he said.
Koim said the new level had posed new challenges, which were many and may not be solved overnight.
“The compliance rate of nine per cent last year, underreporting of K18 billion and an uncollected debt of K5 billion requires our undivided attention urgently,” he said.
“I do not see these figures as a problem, but an opportunity to make a difference.
“Imagine, by this time next year, we increased the compliance rate by 50 per cent, detect and reduce under-reporting by 50 per cent, recover 50 per cent of the outstanding debts, and prevent further under-reporting and uncollected debts accumulating.
“That is the difference I mean here.” Koim said whether one is a janitor, process clerk, auditor or assistant commissioner, everyone had a part to play to make it happen.
He assured the staff he would fight for the employees and for IRC.
“In return, can I count on you to fight for the making of this difference?”
“If it is to be, can it be up to you?
“Can you be the one to take the first step to see the difference?”
Koim will be visiting each division to learn of their work.

Go to this link for more: https://www.thenational.com.pg/koim-challenges-staff/

Featured Post

Cashless in China as I study for my PhD

                                WeChat and Alipay digital payment applications By BETTY GABRIEL WAKIA - posted on PNG Attitude Blog PORT MOR...